Volume 66 Number 2 Article 3 Pages: 78-90
Year 2012 Month 4
Title: Comparison of Soil Nutrition, Tree Performance, and Insect and Disease Occurrence between Organic and Conventional Asian Pear Orchards
Authors: Hyun-Sug Choi, Kyeong-Ho Lim, Mengmeng Gu, Wol-Soo Kim, Do-Ik Kim, Kyeong-Ju Choi and Han-Chan Lee
A conventional and an organic orchard each with 12-year-old ‘Niitaka’ pear (Pyrus pyriforia Nakai) trees
were compared in terms of soil nutrition, tree performance, and insect and disease occurrence in the warm, humid
environment of South Korea from 2008 to 2010. The organic orchard management system had higher weed species
diversity compared to that of the conventional system.
The conventional orchard had higher soil pH, organic
matter, [T-N], [P2O5], [K2O], [MgO], and CEC than the organic orchard on average over the three years but this
did not result in higher foliar [T-N], [P], and [Ca]. Overall fruit shape index, soluble solids concentration, and
color were similar under both management systems, but individual fruit size and fruit yield were both higher and
fruit firmness was lower in the conventional orchard.
Fruit from the organic trees were more damaged by diseases
Estimated fruit production income was not significantly different between the two management systems
in the first two years, but income was 69% higher for the conventional system in year 3 than for the organic
system as a consequence of yield loss from severe pest problems due to an extended period of precipitation in that
summer production season.
Full text download: APS subscribers
ISHS members & pay-per-view
(PDF 822279 bytes)
APS membership administration
ISHS membership administration